The Passive Voice in Fiction: When to Use It and When to Cut It

Never use the passive voice. It is one of those rules handed down with total confidence, usually by someone who has just read a draft full of it. The advice exists for a reason: passive constructions are easy to overuse, and overused they make prose feel bloodless. As a blanket ban, though, it is wrong, and writers who obey it too strictly lose a genuinely useful tool.

Passive voice is a setting on the dial, not a disease. What follows is how it actually works, where it earns its place in fiction, and how to spot the instances that are quietly flattening your pages.

What Passive Voice Actually Is

Passive voice is a construction, not an error. It appears when the subject of a clause receives the action rather than performing it, and it is built from a form of be (or get) plus a past participle.

Active: “Marta unlocked the door.” Passive: “The door was unlocked by Marta.” Truncated passive: “The door was unlocked.”

The agent — the person doing the thing — can be pushed into a “by” phrase or dropped altogether. That mobility is the whole point. Passive voice lets you decide who or what sits at the front of the sentence.

One caution before you start hunting. Not every was is passive. “She was exhausted” does no action to her; it is a linking verb attached to an adjective. “The window was broken” could describe either a state or an event. Counting instances of was tells you nothing useful about your prose.

Three Myths Worth Retiring

• It is grammatically wrong. It is not. Passive voice is standard English and turns up in every register, from legal writing to poetry.
• It is always wordy. Sometimes it is the shortest option available. “Mistakes were made” is briefer than naming who made them — which is precisely why it gets used.
• Good writers avoid it. They do not. They choose it, sentence by sentence, when it does something the active version cannot.

The useful question is never “is this passive?” but “is this passive doing a job?”

When Passive Voice Strengthens Fiction

Passive voice works best when emphasis matters more than the actor. A handful of situations come up again and again.

When the actor is unknown, irrelevant, or deliberately hidden

“The body was found at dawn.” Nobody knows who found it, and the sentence does not need them. The same applies to withheld information: “The lamps had already been lit when we arrived” raises a question without answering it. That is useful for building unease.

When the point-of-view character is on the receiving end

“She was pushed into the corridor” keeps her as the subject and keeps us inside her experience. Rewriting it as “Someone pushed her” drags a faceless someone into the frame and shifts attention off her in the middle of a tense moment. In scenes of helplessness, restraint or violence, the passive is often the closer camera.

When you want a subject to carry across sentences

Cohesion matters more than most advice admits. “The letter arrived on Tuesday. It had been opened, read, and tucked back into its envelope.” The letter stays the subject, so the paragraph moves in one clean line. Flip the second sentence to the active and you must interrupt with a new actor: “Someone had opened it, read it and tucked it back.” Perfectly good English — and a small stumble in a paragraph that was gliding.

For evasion, distance and institutional voice

“Mistakes were made” is a confession with the confessor removed. In dialogue, that evasion is characterisation: you learn something about a person who talks that way. In narration, a dry administrative register can establish a world where people are processed rather than consulted. “The names were taken at the gate. Nobody was told why.”

For rhythm and end weight

English sentences tend to land hardest on their final words. Passive lets you move the interesting noun to the end. “The final entry was written by a dead man” against “A dead man wrote the final entry.” Both are fine sentences. The first makes dead man the punchline.

Where Passive Voice Weakens Your Prose

Passive voice sags when it becomes the default rather than a decision. Watch for these patterns:

• Passive plus nominalisation. “An investigation into the accounts was conducted by the board” becomes “The board investigated the accounts.” Verbs beat abstract nouns pretending to be verbs.
• Consecutive passives with the same hidden agent. Three sentences in a row in which things are done to things, and nobody does anything, flattens pace fast — especially in action scenes.
• “By” phrases that tell us nothing. If the reader already knows who did it, the tag is dead weight. Cut it or flip the sentence.
• Mystery sliding into confusion. Withholding one actor creates suspense. Withholding four in a paragraph makes readers reconstruct who is doing what instead of feeling the scene.
• A chain of receiver-subjects. If every sentence opens with something being acted upon, the paragraph loses forward motion. Eventually someone has to do something.

A Fast Test for Any Sentence

1. Find the verb. Is it a form of be or get followed by a past participle?
2. Ask who performs the action. Are they in the sentence, and does the reader need them there?
3. Read it aloud. If it feels limp or anonymous, try the active version.
4. Compare the two. Keep whichever puts the emphasis where you want it and reads better in context.
5. Check the paragraph around it. Sometimes the apparently weaker sentence is the one holding the subject chain together.

That last step is the one most advice skips. A sentence does not live alone; it lives in a paragraph, and cohesion is a legitimate reason to choose the passive.

Revising Without a Witch-Hunt

Do not aim for zero. Aim for intention.

Mark every passive in a finished scene, then ask three questions of each one. Does the reader need to know who acted? Would the active version be tighter, or merely busier? And which sounds better read aloud? Change the ones that fail all three. Leave the rest exactly as they are.

Do this once per chapter or story, not on every line while drafting — hunting passives mid-flow interrupts the voice you are trying to hear. And if a scene is written in a cool, bureaucratic or evasive register on purpose, a high passive count may be precisely right. Style is a set of choices, and this one belongs on the list.

Photo: suju-foto / Pixabay